Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Joyful Retirement SecretsJoyful Retirement Secrets

Editor's Pick

The Pros and Cons of a Universal Basic Income

Jeffrey Miron

Cash Icon

Proposals to adopt a universal basic income (UBI) raise three questions.

The first is whether a UBI should add to or replace the existing safety net. Adding the program is a nonstarter because the current US fiscal path is already unsustainable.

The second question is whether a UBI would be better than the existing safety set, holding expenditure constant. The answer is probably yes: eliminating TANF, SNAP, Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare, disability insurance, energy assistance, housing subsidies, and more would mean a huge reduction in bureaucracy and a less paternalistic system.

Replacing the current system with a UBI also facilitates the repeal of policies that attempt to redistribute by interfering with the price system (minimum wage laws, rent control, anti-price gouging laws, and more). These policies are often poorly targeted and even counterproductive.

The third question is whether a UBI should be a federal program or left to individual states.

Advocates of anti-poverty spending assume it should be federal, believing the state-by-state approach generates a “race to the bottom.”

Government programs, however, almost always expand, so competition between states plausibly promotes a reasonable balance. Many states redistribute beyond what the federal government mandates; California and Washington, for example, have minimum wages higher than the federal requirement.

Eliminating all federal redistribution, while allowing states to operate UBI programs, thus implies a smaller, less distorting safety net that would still protect the most vulnerable. 

This article appeared on Substack on October 18, 2024. Amelia Heller, a student at Harvard University, co-authored the piece.

You May Also Like

Politics

Former President Trump on Friday said that Israel should attack Iran’s nuclear facilities while mocking President Biden’s answer earlier this week on the subject....

Editor's Pick

Eric Gomez and Benjamin Giltner There were multiple developments in US security assistance to Taiwan in September 2024, but the size of the arms...

Editor's Pick

Jennifer J. Schulp and Jack Solowey What do Yankees tickets and Pokémon cards have in common? If you guessed wish list items for elementary...

Editor's Pick

Colleen Hroncich Nicholas Ellis wants to tell a different story about what it means to flourish. “What does it mean to win at life...